May 25, 2012 a lion would win 60% of the lion vs tiger fights. I personally think there are much better books for elementary students than a topic animal vs animal. Jan 05, 2016 my son wanted this book, but he doesnt like it. In the circuses of ancient rome, exotic beasts were commonly pitted against each other. In the wild, lions live for approximately 1218 years, while in captivity they can live over 24 years. Its the ultimate battle, lion and tiger, who will walk away the winner. People might think that i am from india so i would be biased towards the tiger, but actually, in india, both the tiger and lion are respected. So i was wondering, if a male tiger was to fight a male lion who would win. In a fight between an average adult male tiger and an average adult male lion, id expect some roaring and a bit of fighting but in the end the two would probably go off in different directions with no serious harm done. It had some useful information and at the same time just an ok read form me. Scholastic inc isbn 9780545175715 paperback 32 pages 5.
One day a tiger felt that it was more powerful than the lion and wanted to challenge the lion. Who would win book series by jerry pallotta illustrated by rob bolster published by scholastic inc fair use act 17 u. Lion vs tiger animal vs animal tapatalk free forum. He was disappointed that his mane give the lion at the end the edge and thinks the facts are not correct. Tigers are larger, faster, bite harder, and are used to hunting solo. When it comes to animals of the wild, lions and tigers are some of the most popular and fierce beasts out there. They are listed as a threatened vulnerable species and current wild populations are only around 30,000. Tiger paperback january 5, 2016 by jerry pallotta author. Im in love with big cats ever since i was a kid so i think im educated enough to give you an answer. The book was great to share interesting facts about lions and tigers. Now thinking about it, round 1 should slightly favour the lion. I remember reading a discussion on lion vs tiger a few months ago, in summary. Teacher reads the book except for the story at the end.
It talks about the attributes of the lion and tiger, with little word bubbles the book gives definitions of subject specific words and gives fun facts about the different big cats. If you want to know who would win if a lion and tiger had a fight, you need to read this book to find out who would win. Grizzly bear paperback january 1, 2010 by jerry pallotta author, rob bolster illustrator 5. Nov 10, 2017 who would win book series by jerry pallotta illustrated by rob bolster published by scholastic inc fair use act 17 u. The most common reported circumstance of their meeting is in. Lions have a recognized 8 sub species with the largest getting over 500 pounds. This opinion writing unit allows students to analyze the facts in the lion vs. What would happen if a lion and a tiger met each other. Tigers in zoos live up to 25 years or more, but not by much. The lion will kill a tiger to a fight to the death all day long. Tigers are heavier, weighing up to 800 pounds to the lion s 550.
There are numerous records of fights between them, since many people in the past have wanted the answer to this question and tried to settle it by cruelly pitting them against each other. People have spent countless hours on the lion vs tiger topic. If a lion and tiger got into a fight who would win. Whos the strongest, fastest, biggest and baddestwho would win.
The lions mane can protect its neck, but the tiger is a better fighter. Each book is illustrated with fullcolor pictures and features a pair of animals that rarely. Tiger encounter during the rule of the roman empire. This nonfiction reader compares and contrasts two ferocious big cats. They are more tiger fans out there than lion fans but the lion is simply the better fighter.
Tiger encounters venue colosseum of the rome winner the tigers final verdict tigers defeated lions in the lion vs. But face to face, which would win well, lets talk size first. Jim had christopher read some of it to him one night, and then i read the rest to him the second night. A tiger killed a lion in a fight where the tiger didnt try to attack the maneprotected parts and overpowered the lion using both frontpaws. The life span of tigers in the wild is thought to be about 10 12 years. At the end of the book there is a scenario that has the two animals fight each other using the facts we have just learned about and a winner is determined. Series information in this innovative science series from favorite nonfiction author jerry pallotta, readers will learn about dangerous creatures by asking who would win. See all formats and editions hide other formats and editions. Historically, a comparison of the tiger panthera tigris versus the lion panthera leo has been a popular topic of discussion by hunters, naturalists, artists, and poets, and continues to inspire the popular imagination. Apr 17, 2009 i had been watching a fight between a lion and a tigerlion wins the fight. The contest of the lion against the tiger was a classic pairing and the betting usually favoured the tiger. Male lion vs tigress might be a fair fight but otherwise the tiger should usually win.
It has a lot of interesting facts about lions and tigers. In the past, lions and tigers reportedly competed in the wilderness, where their ranges overlapped in eurasia. Clyde beatty s credability stands at the highest, is because he is giving his opinion upoun experince working with both he is giving his opinion on the fact that he s seen them fight 100 s of times, not only lion vs lion, or tiger vs tiger but lion vs tiger. The roman script shows that it was surprising to see the tiger win. Jun 10, 2015 in a tiger vs lion fight, its likely that a tiger would win. That is the basis of this childrens nonfiction book. Here are the stats tiger weight 200 and 320 kg 440 lb. Kids learn about the lion and tigers anatomies, behaviors, and more. Taking into account a number of factors, including tiger vs lion size, bite force, brain size and behavioral characteristics, this seems logical. Mar 24, 2020 tigers are at least twice as heavy as a jaguar. Read 99 facts of ligers lion vs tiger fights were also common during the era of roman empire. In a fight,size is not the necessary to win,there are five required points to win in the fight 1active 2bold 3determination 4courage 5confidence and all these required points are posses by a lion. Weight matter a lot in a fight among contenders with the same weapons. The biggest advantage the male lion has is a mane to help protect his neck from fatal bites to the jugular.
Lion vs tiger or tiger vs lion is basically overall a hypothetical match between the two animals and who would essentially win, and is an iconic name for the debate. Each book is illustrated with fullcolor pictures and features a pair of animals. Although the lion is a bit faster and it has a protective mane, it would put up a good fight. Tigers are larger and more muscular, they are also faster despite their size tigers are the more intelligent fighter, they protect their head and neck by keeping it back, and seem to think about what they will do where as a lion just charges in. Using a booklet, students and teacher sort facts about the lion and tiger and then fill out the advantages checklist. Jan 27, 2018 tigers are heavier and a little faster but the lion is taller and relentless.
Content area vocabulary use the text and the illustrations on p. May 26, 2010 a fight between a lion and a tiger can go either way if both are healthy. Its quite a strong subject matter to bring up, but seeing as many people are probably killing each other over this, i would like to put my two cents in to hopefully change some peoples opinion on this. The lion and the tiger sums up british arrival, rule and exit from indian subcontinent in just 200 pages and this is a sheer injustice with such a historically rich culture. A list of differences between lion and tiger are given below. A male siberian and a male bengal tiger, they both are bigger than a male african lion. These four big cats are lion, tiger, leopard, and jaguar.
John smith clarke, a british lion tamer, said, in a lecture on the fight between a tiger and a lion given to the glasgow zoological society, while showing the actual fight on the screen, in 100 cases out of 100, the tiger would always beat the lion. So this today is who would win lion versus tiger and jerry paletta writes these books and he takes two different animals and tells you all about the different animals and then you get to help decide which animal you think would win and the book is illustrated by rob bolster and its. It was noon and the lion was fast asleep after a meal. The lion is not big or strong enough to beat the tiger, but the tiger is not specialised or experienced enough to kill the lion. They both have similar traits and are both considerd to have no natural preditors. Male bengal tiger vs male african lion battles comic vine. Jerry pallotta is an awardwinning author of childrens books, including dinosaur christmas, who will guide my sleigh tonight. It was far more agile, it was not so clumsy in its movements, it was equally strong, it was.
Aug 27, 2011 yeah a tiger would win, they are usually bigger than the average lion and they say in england during the 1800s they used to house fights between animals, sometimes theyd have a lion vs a tiger, and the tigers always killed the lions, even bears are said to have been put up against lions, and the lions would get their skulls crushed, so tigers would win, lions arent really that strong and. Thanks for joining me today for our who would win a reading of a super fun book by jerry plata. That is why in boxing we have cathegories by weight. This is not a fight i would want to seebut i thought it may be interesting. This book is packed with photos, charts, illustrations, and amazing facts. Tigers are heavier, weighing up to 800 pounds to the lions 550. Tigers and lions are the most ferocious animals on the earth. Explore classroom activities, puzzles, teacher resources and enrichment pdfs for this book. From quora and wikipedia, various takes on the ageold question of who would win in a fight between a lion and a tiger. Read 99 facts of ligers lion vs tiger fights were also common during the era of roman. Facts and photos provide a contrast between lions and tigers, comparing such aspects as their sizes, brain structure, and abilities. The contest of the lion against the tiger was a classic pairing and the. Lion vs tiger ultimate fight lions fighting to death.
329 1348 383 671 1290 517 764 1196 1284 655 596 1158 628 419 1130 1440 352 1254 825 274 3 654 280 355 424 941 1008 651 1401 597 1179 47 669 901 949 204 1164 1367 477 90